20 Comments
User's avatar
Nathan Rabin's avatar

It's crazy to think that if I finally get around to watching Twin Peaks: The Return, it will be late in the process of writing up James Belushi's life's work in television and film. I know that Twin Peaks: The Return is technically television but I heard this one dude say it was almost as good as a movie.

Expand full comment
Matt Seelig's avatar

If you do Twin Peaks: The Return, then you also have to do Wild Palms. It’s the rules.

Expand full comment
Nathan Rabin's avatar

I can do that!

Expand full comment
DR Darke's avatar

Agreed! WILD PALMS is definitely worth taking a look at, at least partly because you cannot believe a television Network went ahead and greenlit it!

Expand full comment
Roger Stude's avatar

Voted Belushi. Actually surprised that he's in the lead currently, as I assumed it would be a Busey blowout. I just think it might be interesting to look at someone who's had a career under the shadow of his more famous (and kinda legendary) brother, and never reaches major stardom, but still manages to plug away and be a name working actor for decades.

Expand full comment
William B's avatar

Gotta go with the Belush! Frankly I'm curious if his sitcom with Michael Keaton (big fan) is any good. I remember seeing VHS copies for sale of it years, but never checked it out.

Expand full comment
Johnny Socko's avatar

I just remember watching one episode when it originally aired when I was a kid. Who'd have thought that just a few years later the unknown co-star named Michael Keaton would be a huge star, and the guy named Belushi would be doing the same kind of low-key work for the rest of his career...

Expand full comment
Matt Seelig's avatar

Why the Belush? Mostly the fact that his entire career involved humping his dead brother’s corpse, but also the fact that you get to watch the following:

Thief

Trading Places

The Man with One Red Shoe

About Last Night…

Jumpin’ Jack Flash

Little Shop of Horrors

The Principal

Red Heat (which I still need to watch)

Only the Lonely (which I REALLY wanted you to review for a CNR)

Destiny Turns On The Radio (the set was the origin of his feud with David Cross)

Also, I don’t really care about Gary Busey.

Expand full comment
William B's avatar

I like your list. The thing is, well, yes he did trade on both his last name and similar mannerisms in his early work. But somewhere around "About Last Night..." he seemed to emerge as a different actor, surprisingly good at the rat-ta-tat Mamet (or whoever wrote the screenplay version) dialogue. His film career is very middle-of-the-road with some genuinely good films mixed in - usually ensemble pieces. The skinny years (Principal, Taking Care of Business, Mr. Destiny, Red Heat) yielded an uneven pile of movies that are kind of interesting, and also make up his leading man catalog.

If you look back at John's career, it was very punk rock and rough around the edges; his film career, despite a couple of clear classics, was spotty at best - I've never even seen "Old Boyfriends" although I don't hear good things.

Busey I find more interesting as an individual - of the two he seems to be the most whackadoo. However, his film career peaked early on (Buddy Holly) with a couple of gems in the later years (Lethal Weapon, Point Break, Predator 2) before his accident. Then it petered out - I have no idea what he's up to these days, but I hope it's not another Gingerdead Man sequel.

Belushi was the clear winner for me on this one.

Expand full comment
Matt Seelig's avatar

Yeah, the only Busey films I could think of off the top of my head are Rookie of the Year and Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas. I don't know what more there is to say about the latter, and it's interesting to contrast the former with Little Big League, but.

Expand full comment
Neurozach's avatar

Frankly, I thought he was surprisingly great in the David Duchovny-directed “Playing By Heart”.

Expand full comment
Matt Seelig's avatar

Now, Jake Busey, as part of a My Year of Nepotism feature, THAT would be interesting.

Expand full comment
Gabriel Taylor 3DCB's avatar

Gary Busey is the poor man's Nick Nolte. James Belushi is boring. But this is just one Cheeseburger's opinion

Expand full comment
Gabriel Taylor 3DCB's avatar

But it does look like Belushi was in a lot of cool movies!

Expand full comment
Johnny Socko's avatar

As much as I think that Busey is simply a more interesting performer to watch than Belushi, he's also pretty well-known and well-covered in the media landscape, to the point where he is now a meme. For that reason, I voted Belushi -- a dependable actor who has delivered some solid performances in movies & shows both great and...otherwise.

Expand full comment
Jess Whitehead's avatar

Not sure why I voted Belushi. Maybe it’s because I feel a little bad that later Busey is just watching a man with brain damage. Granted, it’s his own fault but still...

Expand full comment
Matt Heffernan's avatar

I am very late to this, but I voted Belushi because of the filmography. Specifically, how he became, for a very brief period around 1990, an A-list (or at least B+) leading man. He headed up some big releases and quickly had a more impressive film career than either his brother or Busey.

Expand full comment
Jimmy Barnes's avatar

Should be considered that Busey's accident was 1988 -- incidentally I watched Silver Bullet a couple days ago (released '86) and his performance (and clear improvisation at times) is very good...

Expand full comment
DR Darke's avatar

I went with Jim Belushi because while he's been in a lot of garbage, much of it is really interesting garbage — like WILD PALMS, Wag the Dog, the live-action Underdog movie, Abraxis and Traces of Red.

Expand full comment
Neurozach's avatar

Busey is the easy choice. I think there is more room for surprise with Belushi, though finding said surprises will involve wading through more dreck, which you know we all love.

Expand full comment